Overview

Intellectual Merit
The research employs a novel approach for comparative analyses of meanings of responsible innovation and ethics in bioengineering, while cultivating socially-responsible cultures of R&D among graduate students, faculty, and outside practitioners in genetic engineering and synthetic biology (bioengineering). It innovates in four key respects: 1) it focuses on bioengineering, specifically in areas in which engineering ethics programs have not routinely been applied, genetic engineering and synthetic biology; 2) it evaluates an example pedagogy of engaged scholarship, student facilitation of focus groups, for learning and cultivating ethical cultures; 3) it uses framings of responsible innovation and appreciative inquiry as key parts of the dialogue about ethical cultures in bioengineering; and 4) it compares meanings of responsible innovation across four sectors of bioengineering: government, academe, industry, and non-profit organizations. Twelve focus groups (three from each sector), pre- and post-surveys, and a values-mapping tool are being used for data collection. Example hypotheses tested include: 1) that participants within types of organizational communities conceptualize responsible innovation for bioengineering in similar ways sharing several secondary values as well as core values (tight coalitions); 2) participants across types of organizations differ in conceptions of responsible innovation, but share some policy core and secondary values (loose coalitions); and 3) interest in responsible innovation and ethics, on average, increase in both external-participants and internal-facilitators after the focus groups (versus pre-focus groups). The project promises to contribute to theory and methodology in Science and Technology Studies, science and technology policy, and ethics education, as well as serve as an example of the practice of “engaged scholarship,” by which the activities of academe meet the needs of external communities and vice versa.Broader Impacts
Graduate students in the Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) program and the Initiative to Maximize Student Diversity (IMSD) program at NCSU, with faculty guidance, will serve as facilitators for reflective conversations with stakeholders outside of NCSU to form more robust community understandings of “ethical cultures” and responsible innovation in bioengineering. This grant provides an opportunity for IMSD and GES students to be engaged in the community and have hands-on experience in cultivating ethics and responsible innovation. In doing so, the project will serve to:- Better define what constitutes an “ethical culture” or culture of responsible innovation in bioengineering from bottom-up conversations,
- Increase GES and IMSD graduate students’ abilities to reflect on their own work in bioengineering by understanding challenges and opportunities in diverse organizational contexts,
- Enhance outside participants’ desire for future moral reflection about bioengineering and what it means to responsibly innovate, and
- Evaluate the effectiveness of the engaged scholarship method of “learning by facilitating” for ethics education of graduate students.
Leadership Team
Principal Investigator

Co-Principal Investigator

Co-Principal Investigator

Co-Investigator

Support
Made possible by


Back to top